Front Tires vs. Rear Tires: Where Do New Ones Belong? Experts Weigh In

When it comes to vehicle maintenance, tire placement is a crucial aspect that can significantly impact safety and performance. The question of whether to install new tires on the front or rear of a car has been a topic of much debate among automotive experts.

With safety as our priority, we’ve consulted with seasoned professionals to bring you a detailed analysis that addresses all your concerns.

Understanding the Dynamics: Front vs. Rear Tire Placement

The placement of new tires on a vehicle isn’t just a matter of preference; it’s a strategic decision that involves understanding the dynamics of your car. A blow-out on a front tire can lead to a sudden loss of steering control, making it a potentially dangerous situation. On the other hand, the rear tires play a pivotal role in maintaining the car’s stability, especially during emergency maneuvers or on wet surfaces.

Front Tire Placement

Steering Control and Hydroplaning Resistance Experts who favor placing new tires on the front argue that the front wheels are responsible for steering and most of the braking force. New tires, with their deeper treads, offer better grip and resistance to hydroplaning, which is critical for maintaining control during heavy braking or on wet roads.

A specialist said: Well, there is some logic to that question’s answer. Think for a minute:

A blow-out on a front wheel will cause a dramatic loss of steering capability and the car will almost instantly slew in the direction of the blown tire. In the US that would most likely throw the car:

• Into oncoming traffic if the left front tire blows
• Or into the shoulder (and maybe ditch/guardrail) if the right front tire blows

Rear tires? Not as catastrophic an event at all.

Not good, but steering, while affected, is not seriously compromised.

Put your best tires in front and the absolutely best one? Left front in the US and right front in Japan & the UK.

Rear Tire Placement

Those advocating for new tires on the rear emphasize the importance of stability. The rear tires help prevent oversteer, which can occur when the rear of the car loses grip and swings out. This is particularly important in wet conditions, where worn rear tires can lead to a loss of vehicle control.

A Specialist said: You always want your best tires in the rear.

One thing that was learned long ago is that failure of a rear wheel in any way tends to cause the car to spin and the driver to lose control.

Early cars with mechanical brakes only had brakes on the non-pivoting rear wheels. Applying the mechanical brakes hard enough to lock the rear wheels at speed would send the car into the ditch, which was usually fatal in turn-of-the-20th century accidents.

Early antilock brake systems often only kept the rear wheels from locking up, as those are the ones you really don’t want locking up!

Tire tread diverts water so the rubber tire makes contact with the road surface rather than floating atop the water. Little to no tread means zero traction if any significant amount of water is covering the pavement. This is as bad as locking as wheel as far as controlling the vehicle goes. If the rear end slides out and the vehicle ‘swaps ends’, you’re likely heading to the ditch or the oncoming lane.

Expert Opinions and Best Practices

Racing Perspective

A racing expert points out that while oversteer can be managed by skilled drivers, it can be terrifying for the average driver. For front-wheel-drive vehicles, this expert suggests putting new tires on the back to prevent the front tires from locking up during panic braking.

Response from an enthusiast: There are diverging opinions about this but if I have to buy two tires only, I always prefer to have the new ones on the front axle for the following reasons:

Directional stability. Since new tires have a greater slip angle (torsion of the tire contact area relative to wheel angle) the directional stability is worsened if the slip angle of the rear axle is greater than that of the front one.

Behavior in bends. At high speed on dry roads, cars (even front wheels drive) always have a slight oversteering tendency. It is reduced with the new tires at the front, but increased with them at the rear. On slippery roads with used tires at the front, cars understeer and may even refuse to turn. They oversteer with the new tires at the front, which I prefer because an oversteer is more controllable than a front axle loosing all grip.

Aquaplaning resistance : it is better with new tires since their grooves are deeper. Aquaplaning always happens on the front, never at the rear because the rear tires follow the track on which the front tires have expelled most of the water layer.

Braking. Since 80 to 85% of an emergency braking is done by the front wheels, braking distances will be much shorter on a wet surface with the new tires at the front. On a dry road, there won’t be so much difference, even if braking would be a little bit shorter with the used tires at the front.

Wear. On a front wheel drive car, which has about 65% of its weight on the front tractive axle, the front tires wear much more quickly. Therefore, thread wear will equalize if the new tires are at the front, so and as Tony Li wrote, we skip a rear-front wheels swap. Only one swap will be needed when the front tires are about half worn.

Directional Stability and Handling

Another specialist highlights the importance of directional stability and handling in bends. New tires on the front axle improve high-speed stability and reduce oversteering tendencies on dry roads.

Aquaplaning and Braking

Addressing aquaplaning resistance, one professional notes that new tires are more effective at dispersing water, which is vital since aquaplaning typically affects the front tires first.

Tire Wear and Replacement

From a wear perspective, front tires on front-wheel-drive cars tend to wear out faster. Placing new tires on the front can help equalize tread wear, reducing the need for frequent tire rotations.

Conclusion

Making an Informed Decision The consensus among automotive specialists is that there is no one-size-fits-all answer. The decision should be based on your vehicle type, driving habits, and typical road conditions. For those who drive predominantly on dry roads, new tires on the front might be the best option. However, if you often encounter wet or slippery conditions, placing new tires on the rear could be the safer choice.

A former Toyota and Hyundai Service Advisor said: I spent two years as a Hyundai and a Toyota service advisor. We were trained that the tires with the most tread depth went on the rear regardless of where the drive wheels were located. We were shown videos of the rear end swinging around in emergency maneuver situations and the driver losing control when the rear tires had the least tread depth as compared to the front tires. I took the information below from a popular mechanics article that explains it best.

The myth: When replacing only two tires, the new ones go on the front.

The truth: Rear tires provide stability, and without stability, steering or braking on a wet or even damp surface might cause a spin. If you have new tires up front, they will easily disperse water while the half-worn rears will go surfing: The water will literally lift the worn rear tires off the road. If you're in a slight corner or on a crowned road, the car will spin out so fast you won't be able to say, "Oh, fudge!"

There is no "even if" to this one. Whether you own a front-, rear- or all-wheel-drive car, truck, or SUV, the tires with the most tread go on the rear. Don't believe it?

For the ultimate in safety and performance, it’s recommended to replace all four tires at the same time. But if you’re only replacing two, consider the expert advice we’ve shared to make an informed decision that ensures your peace of mind on the road. And to wind up, this is what one of the renowned tire manufacturers had to say:

Here is Michelin’s answer:

“Deeper tread tires on the rear axle provide better handling, wet grip, and evacuate water, thereby helping to avoid oversteer and loss of vehicle stability on wet surfaces. Deeper tread tires on the front axle can improve wet straight line braking and stopping distance. If only two tires are being replaced, Michelin generally recommends they be installed on the rear axle in the absence of a tire service professional's recommendation or consumer's preference to the contrary.”

Don’t forget to share it