Ways to Avoid Knocking in an SI Engine When the Compression Ratio is Increased?

There are some ways to avoid knocking in an SI engine when the compression ratio is increased, such as using a higher octane fuel, retarding the spark timing, cooling the intake air, adding water injection, or adding EGR.

Knocking is a phenomenon that occurs in spark ignition (SI) engines when the fuel-air mixture in the cylinder detonates prematurely due to high temperature and pressure. Knocking can cause damage to the engine components, reduce performance and efficiency, and increase emissions. Therefore, it is desirable to avoid knocking in SI engines as much as possible.

One of the factors that affects knocking is the compression ratio, which is the ratio of the volume of the cylinder when the piston is at the bottom dead center (BDC) to the volume when the piston is at the top dead center (TDC). The higher the compression ratio, the higher the temperature and pressure of the fuel-air mixture at the end of the compression stroke, and the more likely it is to knock. However, increasing the compression ratio also has some benefits, such as improving thermal efficiency, power output, and fuel economy. Therefore, it is desirable to increase the compression ratio in SI engines as much as possible without causing knocking.

Read Also: Understanding Engine Knocking: Causes, Signs, Prevention, Troubleshooting, and Repair

There are some ways to avoid knocking in an SI engine when the compression ratio is increased. These include:

1. Using a higher octane fuel: The octane rating of a fuel is a measure of its resistance to knocking. The higher the octane rating, the more resistant the fuel is to detonation. Therefore, using a higher octane fuel can prevent or reduce knocking in an SI engine with a high compression ratio. The octane rating of a fuel depends on its chemical composition and additives. For example, ethanol has a higher octane rating than gasoline, and adding tetraethyl lead or methyl tert-butyl ether (MTBE) can increase the octane rating of gasoline.
2. Retarding the spark timing: The spark timing is the moment when the spark plug ignites the fuel-air mixture in the cylinder. Retarding the spark timing means delaying it until a later point in the compression stroke. This reduces the time available for combustion and lowers the peak temperature and pressure of the fuel-air mixture. Therefore, retarding the spark timing can prevent or reduce knocking in an SI engine with a high compression ratio. However, retarding the spark timing also reduces thermal efficiency and power output, and increases exhaust temperature and emissions.
3. Cooling the intake air: The intake air is the air that enters the engine through the intake manifold. Cooling the intake air means reducing its temperature before it reaches the cylinder. This lowers the temperature and density of the fuel-air mixture at the end of the intake stroke, and reduces its tendency to knock. Therefore, cooling the intake air can prevent or reduce knocking in an SI engine with a high compression ratio. Cooling the intake air can be achieved by using an intercooler, which is a heat exchanger that transfers heat from the intake air to another medium, such as water or ambient air. 
4. Adding water injection: Water injection is a technique that involves injecting a small amount of water into the cylinder along with or after the fuel-air mixture. The water absorbs heat from combustion and lowers the peak temperature and pressure of the fuel-air mixture. Therefore, adding water injection can prevent or reduce knocking in an SI engine with a high compression ratio. Water injection can also increase thermal efficiency and power output by increasing the specific heat ratio of the working fluid.
5. Adding exhaust gas recirculation (EGR): EGR is a technique that involves recirculating a portion of the exhaust gas back into the intake manifold. The exhaust gas dilutes and displaces some of the fresh intake air, reducing its oxygen content and lowering its temperature. Therefore, adding EGR can prevent or reduce knocking in an SI engine with a high compression ratio. EGR can also reduce emissions of nitrogen oxides (NOx) by lowering combustion temperature.

Conclusion

Knocking is a harmful phenomenon that occurs in SI engines when the fuel-air mixture detonates prematurely due to high temperature and pressure. Increasing the compression ratio can increase the risk of knocking, but also improve thermal efficiency, power output, and fuel economy. There are some ways to avoid knocking in an SI engine when the compression ratio is increased, such as using a higher octane fuel, retarding the spark timing, cooling the intake air, adding water injection, or adding EGR. These methods have different effects on performance, efficiency, and emissions, and require different modifications and costs. Therefore, the optimal solution depends on the specific engine design and operating conditions. Remember to always consult your owner’s manual or service manual for more information and guidance on how to maintain and repair your car.

Don’t forget to share it