How safe are self-driving or autonomous driving cars?

Self-driving or autonomous driving cars are vehicles that can operate without human intervention, using artificial intelligence, sensors, cameras, and other technologies to navigate the roads and avoid collisions.

Self-driving cars have the potential to offer many benefits, such as reducing traffic congestion, improving fuel efficiency, enhancing mobility and accessibility, and saving lives. However, self-driving cars also face many challenges and risks, such as technical glitches, cyberattacks, ethical dilemmas, legal liability, and public acceptance. In this article, we will explore how safe are self-driving cars compared to human-driven cars, and what factors affect their safety performance.

According to the World Health Organization (WHO), more than 1.3 million people die every year in road traffic crashes, and another 20 to 50 million are injured or disabled. The majority of these crashes are caused by human error, such as speeding, drunk driving, distracted driving, fatigue, or poor judgment. Therefore, one of the main arguments in favor of self-driving cars is that they can eliminate or reduce human error and improve road safety.

However, self-driving cars are not flawless either. They rely on complex software and hardware systems that can malfunction or fail under certain conditions. For example, self-driving cars may have difficulty detecting or responding to unexpected situations, such as road debris, bad weather, or pedestrians jaywalking. Moreover, self-driving cars may be vulnerable to cyberattacks that can compromise their security or functionality. Additionally, self-driving cars may pose ethical challenges when they have to make decisions that involve trade-offs between different values or interests. For instance, how should a self-driving car decide who to save or harm in a crash scenario?

The safety of self-driving cars depends on several factors, such as the level of automation, the testing and validation methods, the regulatory framework, and the human-machine interaction. The level of automation refers to how much control the vehicle has over the driving task and how much intervention the human driver needs to provide. The Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) defines six levels of automation from 0 (no automation) to 5 (full automation). Currently, most self-driving cars are at level 2 (partial automation) or level 3 (conditional automation), which means that they still require human supervision and intervention in some situations. The higher levels of automation (level 4 and level 5) are still under development and testing.

The testing and validation methods refer to how self-driving cars are evaluated for their safety and performance before they are deployed on public roads. Testing can be done in simulated environments, closed tracks, or real-world settings. Each method has its advantages and limitations. Simulated environments can test millions of scenarios in a short time and low cost, but they may not capture all the complexities and uncertainties of real-world driving. Closed tracks can test specific scenarios in a controlled environment, but they may not reflect the diversity and variability of real-world traffic. Real-world settings can test how self-driving cars interact with other road users and environmental factors, but they may pose ethical and legal risks if something goes wrong.

The regulatory framework refers to the laws and regulations that govern the development and deployment of self-driving cars. Different countries and regions have different approaches and standards for regulating self-driving cars. Some are more permissive and supportive of innovation, while others are more cautious and restrictive of risk. The regulatory framework affects the safety of self-driving cars by setting the rules and requirements for testing, certification, licensing, liability, data protection, cybersecurity, ethics, and consumer protection.

The human-machine interaction refers to how human drivers and passengers communicate with and trust self-driving cars. Human drivers may need to monitor the vehicle's status and intervene when necessary. Passengers may need to provide input or feedback to the vehicle's system. Both drivers and passengers may need to understand how the vehicle operates and what its limitations are. The human-machine interaction affects the safety of self-driving cars by influencing the level of situational awareness, attention, trust, comfort, and satisfaction of the human users.

In conclusion, self-driving cars are not inherently safer or riskier than human-driven cars. They have different strengths and weaknesses that affect their safety performance. The safety of self-driving cars depends on how well they are designed, tested, regulated, and used by humans. As self-driving technology advances and matures, it is expected that self-driving cars will become safer than human-driven cars in most situations. However, it is unlikely that self-driving cars will ever be completely safe or error-free in all situations. Therefore, it is important to balance the benefits and risks of self-driving cars and to ensure that they are integrated into a safe and sustainable transportation system.

Don’t forget to share it